Then What Happened? — Rules

Overview

Then What Happened? is a competitive card game for 1 to 5 players.

A tale unfolds as 13 story cards are revealed, one at a time.

Players pick from the remaining 39 cards in the deck, answering questions and discussing the story.

Answering questions and collecting sets of cards scores points. The player who scores the most points wins.

Back to top ↑


Components

You’ll use a specially designed 52-card Poker deck. However, this isn’t just any deck of playing cards. This deck tells a story!

Story cards

Cards belonging to the Hearts suit are Story cards. In addition to rank and suit, these 13 cards have the text of the story printed on them.

Question cards

Cards belonging to the other three suits (Diamonds, Spades, Clubs) are Question cards. In addition to rank and suit, these 39 cards each have a discussion question printed on them.

Each discussion question begins with one of six words: Who, What, Where, When, Why, How. These words function as the Question Category for each card.

Back to top ↑


Setup

  1. Set up the story. Lay out Hearts cards from left to right, 2 to Ace, in easy view of all players. Then flip the cards face-down.
  2. Form the draw pile. Shuffle the 39 Question cards. Place them in a face-down draw pile in easy reach of all players.
  3. Choose the starting Storyteller. The Storyteller is the first player in turn order. Play proceeds to the left (clockwise). Use the deck box as the Storyteller token; it will be passed at the end of each round.
  4. Begin reading the story. The Storyteller reveals the first three story cards (2, 3, and 4 of Hearts) and reads the text aloud.
  5. Deal starting hands. In turn order, each player draws two cards from the top of the draw pile. Players hold these cards in their hands. Every time an Ace is drawn, pause while the Storyteller reveals the next story card and reads the text aloud.
  6. Fill the Market. The Storyteller fills the Market for the first round, as described in Step 6: Fill the Market.

Back to top ↑


Playing a Round

Each round has six steps: Then What Happened? → Reveal a story card → Pick cards → Match & Discuss → Clean up → Fill the Market.

Step 1: Then What Happened?

Everyone looks at the Storyteller and asks, “Then what happened?”

Step 2: Reveal a story card

The Storyteller reveals the leftmost face-down story card and reads it aloud to the group.

Step 3: Pick cards

Starting with the Storyteller, each player takes 1 card from the Market and adds it to their hand.

Step 4: Match & Discuss

Starting with the Storyteller, each player may discuss one card from their hand that matches a face-up story card. It’s optional, but it’s how you score points!

Step 5: Clean up

Tidy the table and pass the Storyteller role.

Step 6: Fill the Market

The new Storyteller draws cards into the Market one at a time, one more card than the number of players (4 players → 5 cards).

Back to top ↑


Game End

The game ends in one of two ways. Either way, finish with a final discussion and an epilogue, then go to Scoring.

Back to top ↑


Scoring

Points are scored at the end of the game based on cards in your score set—the cards face-up on the table in front of you. You are rewarded for reading and answering the questions on these cards.

Cards held in hand at the end of the game score no points, and are not considered part of your score set.

Discussion points

Set collection points

A card can count toward more than one scoring set.

Aces act as category wild cards.

See Clarifications & miscellaneous rules for the finer points of set collection scoring.

Ties

In the event of a tie, compare each tied player’s highest-ranked card in their score set (Aces are high). The player with the highest-ranked card wins.

If those cards are the same rank, the player with more cards of that rank in their score set wins.

If players are still tied, victory is shared.

Back to top ↑


Concepts & Terms

Story cards
Hearts. These have text of the story printed on them.
Question cards
Diamonds, Spades, and Clubs. These have discussion questions printed on them, underneath some lovely artwork.
Round

The game is played in rounds. Each round is the six steps under “Playing a Round,” beginning with “Then what happened?”

Because the first three story cards are revealed during setup, a game lasts no more than 10 rounds. However, many games last only 7 or 8 rounds, because the story advances every time an Ace is drawn from the draw pile.

Market stack
Each round, cards are placed in an overlapping column. The top half of each card is visible while the bottom half is covered by the card below it. The uncovered card at the bottom of the stack is free to pick up; covered cards have a cost (see Step 3).
Hand
The cards a player holds, hidden from the other players. Starting cards and cards picked from the Market go into your hand, and your hand carries over from round to round. At the end of each round, you may hold no more than 3 cards. Cards still in hand at the end of the game score no points.
Discussion
Players are encouraged to read and discuss the questions printed on Diamonds, Spades, and Clubs cards. This happens during Step 4, when a player chooses a card from their hand whose rank matches a face-up story card.
Score set
The discussed cards a player has placed face-up on the table in front of them. Only cards in your score set score points.
Card orientation

Every card in a score set has been discussed, and its orientation shows how much it’s worth.

Bottom-decking

In many card games, players move cards to a discard pile. Later, when the draw pile runs out, they shuffle the discard pile and then form a new draw pile.

Bottom-decking eliminates this administrative busy work. Instead of all the discarding and shuffling, players simply pick up the draw pile and place unused cards at the bottom.

This happens during the Clean-up step (Step 5), when the Storyteller bottom-decks any cards left in the Market stack. Also, all players must bottom-deck cards in excess of their 3-card hand limit.

Do not pay attention to the order of bottom-decked cards. The order does not matter and there’s no need to shuffle them, but players should not seek to place the cards in any particular order.

Players may not bottom-deck cards voluntarily, only as directed by the rules.

Over-ranked
A question card ranked higher than the highest face-up story card is ‘over-ranked.’ Its question can’t be discussed yet, so it stays in the player’s hand until the story catches up. Aces are high (they rank above Kings), so they can only be discussed after the Ace of Hearts is revealed.

Back to top ↑


Clarifications & miscellaneous rules

Aces in a score set are category wild cards at the end of the game

Category set collection is an important way to score points. In Scoring, players declare which category each of their Aces belongs to. This makes collecting Aces a smart move.

During the game, Aces have no category. An Ace only reaches your score set if you discuss it after the Ace of Hearts is revealed.

Aces in hand are worthless at the end of the game

There’s no guarantee you’ll get to place your Ace in your score set. The game might end early because the draw pile doesn’t have enough cards to fill the Market.

In this case, an Ace left in your hand has no effect.

Mix-n-match set collection

A single card can count toward more than one scoring set.

Example: you have eight cards in your score set; 6 have different categories and earn 6 points (All categories set). Additionally, you have three “Why” category cards and earn 3 points (3-of-a-kind categories set). A single Why card counts towards both sets.

Example: you have the Ace of Diamonds, plus other cards in your score set. In addition to scoring 2 points by itself and acting as a category wild card, the Ace of Diamonds also counts toward the “3 Diamonds” set collection. The Ace of Diamonds in your score set might yield a great many points.

Orientation only matters in your score set

Cards in your hand and in the Market have no orientation. Only cards in your score set are placed horizontally or vertically.

Re-reading the story

Anyone may pick up a face-up story card to re-read it at any time. Just put it back in its place in the row afterward.

Every game will be unique

Just for fun: there are over twenty quattuordecillion possible combinations of cards in the 39-card question draw pile. The exact number is:

20,397,882,081,197,443,358,640,281,739,902,897,356,800,000,000

Back to top ↑


Solo game

Back to top ↑


Play online

Want to try the game without a deck of cards? Play Then What Happened? in your browser.

Back to top ↑


First time teach

Back to top ↑